Great Circle Associates List-Managers
(December 1992)

Indexed By Date: [Previous] [Next] Indexed By Thread: [Previous] [Next]

Subject: Posts by non-members
From: rick @ vsystem . wimsey . bc . ca (Rick Vandenberg)
Organization: Vandenberg Systems Research, Vancouver BC
Date: Thu, 31 Dec 92 13:26:36 PST
To: list-managers @ GreatCircle . COM

I've written a file- and list-server, and have a question about
how I can have it handle the following situation:

On one particular list, posts are allowed by non-members; that is, the
poster does not need to be subscribed.  The reason for this is that one
of the addresses on the list points to a mail<->news gateway on another
system.  Messages may come from any of a thousand users on this

Normal operation of the mailing list is to have Reply-To: point back to
the mailing list.  Sender: is set to MAILER-DAEMON, so bounces don't go
back to the list.

The difficulty occurs where a non-member posts from another site.  The
Reply-To: points back to the list, therefore all replies will usually go
back to the list.  Because the original poster is not subscribed to the
list, it's doubtful that he/she will ever get a response.

What I'd like to know is how other administrators handle something like
this.  I suppose I could build in some logic to flag a site as a
gateway, and then have the software send a message to any
non-member that is not at a gateway site.  Something like "If you want a
response to your message, you'd better subscribe quick!".  Or perhaps I
could have the software remove the Reply-To: header in these situations.

Any ideas?


Rick Vandenberg             rick @
 vsystem .
 wimsey .
 bc .
Vandenberg Systems Research For more information about V-MailServer
204 - 2255 West 5th Ave.    send a blank e-mail to
Vancouver, BC V6K 4K1       vmail-info-request @
 vsystem .
 wimsey .
 bc .

Indexed By Date Previous: Archive-server for System V
From: rick @ ssg . com (Rick Emerson)
From: (nil)
Indexed By Thread Previous: Archive-server for System V
From: rick @ ssg . com (Rick Emerson)
From: (nil)

Search Internet Search