Great Circle Associates List-Managers
(May 1997)

Indexed By Date: [Previous] [Next] Indexed By Thread: [Previous] [Next]

Subject: Re: Threats from an unsubscribed list member
From: "Paul L. Moses" <theseus @ dgs . dgsys . com>
Date: Sat, 10 May 1997 12:07:56 -0400
To: List-Managers @ GreatCircle . COM
In-reply-to: <199705100133 . SAA22391 @ honor . greatcircle . com>

+From: murr rhame <murr @
 vnet .
+On Fri, 9 May 1997, Paul L. Moses wrote:

+> This same individual also compiled an index to resources in my archives
+> WITHOUT asking and again had to be told that he needed permission to do
+> that...
+I don't understand the conflict here.  Would you please add some details?
+I don't see how someone compiling an "unauthorized" index of your archives
+could be a problem.

To begin with, an unauthorized person making a "derivative work" (such as
an index) based on the copyrighted works of others is copyright

Secondly, in this particular case, the person was indexing all the
"pro"-posts on a controversial subject.  This subject had been debated
extensively and a small, vocal, extreme minority had shouted down more
educated and informed (and cautious) viewpoints.  Finally I stepped in and
asserted some basic facts and made the subject off-topic.  I was concerned
that people would follow this index and reach a one-sided conclusion that
could be harmful.

Lastly, I found it annoying and rude that someone else would rifle through
my archives and announce to the world a fait accompli without ever asking
me.  I keep my archives open as a courtesy and service to anyone who is
interested, and I expect a certain level of courtesy in return.


the Training-Nutrition mailing list
"Breaking news from the top of the food chain."

Indexed By Date Previous: comments on ml help file requested
From: arielle @ taronga . com (Stephanie da Silva)
Next: [no subject]
From: the-true-highlander @ juno . com (Duncan McCloud)
Indexed By Thread Previous: Re: Threats from an unsubscribed list member
From: murr rhame <murr @ vnet . net>
Next: announcement list on listproc vs. majordomo
From: awest @ webster . m-w . com (Amy West)

Search Internet Search